Skip to content

Front des gauches

Live news from the left

How to Recruit Successfully and Find the Ideal Candidate for Your Business?

A failed hire is costly, but a poorly calibrated hiring process costs even more. Most unfilled positions aren’t the result of…

Entretien d'embauche professionnel entre une responsable RH et un candidat dans un bureau moderne

A failed hire is costly, but a poorly calibrated one costs even more. Most unfilled vacancies are not due to a lack of candidates: France Travail’s survey of vacancies published in 2025 distinguishes between recruitment processes still underway, vacancies cancelled by the employer, and positions left unfilled because no suitable candidate was found.

Among the reasons reported for the latter are a lack of skills, experience or training, as well as a lack of motivation. The problem often lies in the gap between the profile sought and what the company can realistically offer.

Recruitment pressures and local labour markets: get the balance right before sourcing

Recruitment difficulties are not evenly distributed. Pressure remains high in construction, maintenance and healthcare, while the overall recruitment pressure indicator began to fall in 2024. Using the same sourcing strategy for a maintenance technician in a rural area and an administrative manager in a major city means ignoring the realities of the local market.

Before drafting a job ad, we recommend looking at three factors: the number of active candidates in the target labour market, the salaries offered by competing employers in the same sector, and the actual working conditions on offer (hours, travel, remote work). A role paying below the local median will naturally attract less experienced or less stable candidates.

Specialist platforms can help compare this data with available talent pools, including https://campus-recrutement.fr, which connects companies with candidates from targeted fields of study.

Redefining the “ideal” candidate in the context of the role

The ideal candidate is not someone who ticks every box on a theoretical job description. It is someone the company can attract, pay and help succeed in the local context of the role. A production manager hired at 15% above the local market rate is likely to stay. The same profile hired at 10% below it may leave within six months.

Limiting the list of “essential” criteria to three measurable technical skills and one behavioural criterion that can be observed in an interview cuts through the noise without compromising the quality of the selection process.

Recruiter reviewing CVs and assessing applications at their desk

Pay transparency in job ads: what’s changing

The EU Pay Transparency Directive requires candidates to receive information about the starting salary or salary range. It also prohibits employers from asking candidates about their salary history. French law has not yet transposed all of these provisions, but companies that get ahead of this requirement are seeing a direct impact on the quality of applications.

Including a salary range in the job ad screens candidates upfront. Those who apply already accept the financial terms, reducing dropouts at the end of the process. By contrast, saying “depending on experience” without giving any indication leads to unnecessary interviews with candidates whose expectations are incompatible with the role.

  • Set the range based on the internal pay scale and local benchmarks, not the department’s minimum budget
  • Include variable pay (bonuses, profit-sharing, benefits in kind) in the published range to avoid misunderstandings
  • Prepare objective criteria for determining where a candidate falls within the range (sector experience, certifications, language skills)

A realistic salary range attracts more qualified candidates than an ad that says nothing about pay.

Candidate assessment: structure interviews to reduce bias

An unstructured interview leads to decisions based more on personal impressions than on skills. The solution is a simple protocol: ask every candidate the same questions in the same order, complete a competency-based scorecard immediately after each interview, and make the decision as a group with at least two assessors.

Questions that assess real skills

Situational questions (“Tell me about a time you had to manage a conflict with a supplier”) reveal more than generic questions about strengths and weaknesses. They require candidates to draw on concrete experience and allow recruiters to assess their reasoning skills, not just how they present themselves.

Three to five situational questions aligned with the role’s critical competencies are enough to distinguish between candidates. Beyond that, the interview gets longer without yielding more useful information.

AI tools and application screening: the regulatory framework

The AI Act classifies certain uses of artificial intelligence in recruitment as high-risk systems. Using an automated tool to screen CVs or score applications requires human oversight, documentation of the criteria used, and an assessment of the risk of algorithmic bias.

In practice, an ATS that filters by keywords may exclude relevant candidates who have described their experience differently. Manually reviewing a regular sample of applications rejected by the tool (one in five, for example) can help uncover these blind spots.

Group of candidates waiting in a modern waiting room before their job interviews

Retention starts during recruitment: what happens before the first day

Recruitment does not end when the contract is signed. The period between accepting the offer and the first day on the job is critical. A candidate who hears nothing for three weeks is more likely to accept a counteroffer from another employer.

  • Send a welcome message with practical information (access badge, equipment, first-week schedule) within 48 hours of acceptance
  • Assign an operational point of contact (not the direct manager) to get in touch with the new hire before they start
  • Prepare a 30-day onboarding plan with progressive goals and scheduled check-ins

A structured onboarding process significantly reduces early turnover. The cost of replacing a hire far exceeds the cost of a well-designed onboarding programme.

Effective recruitment depends less on finding the perfect candidate than on aligning what the role requires, what the company offers and what the local market can provide. Every stage of the process, from writing the job ad to onboarding, acts as a filter that either strengthens or weakens this alignment.

How to Recruit Successfully and Find the Ideal Candidate for Your Business?